Bioshock 1 [TESTED – METHOD]
But the atmosphere ? The sound design ? The writing ? Unmatched. Modern games have better graphics and smoother controls, but few have the guts to ask the player to think about Objectivism, free will, and addiction while they are mowing down maniacs with a tommy gun.
There are very few games that I can point to and say, "That moment changed how I look at the medium." Half-Life 2 did it. The Last of Us did it. But sitting at the very top of that list, rusted and dripping with sea water, is BioShock . bioshock 1
Warning: Light spoilers for the opening hour of BioShock (2007) below. But the atmosphere