Then there’s the Beast, the mute, half-paralyzed super-assassin. His voice, a soft, high-pitched whisper, becomes even more unnerving in English: “What’s the matter? You look like you’ve seen a ghost.” It’s a performance that understands the character’s quiet menace is far scarier than any scream.

Let’s be clear. Purists are right to champion subtitles. The original Cantonese performances capture Stephen Chow’s specific comic timing and the lyrical flow of the dialogue. But to dismiss the English version of Kung Fu Hustle is to miss out on a brilliantly unhinged alternate experience—one that understands the assignment perfectly.

And here’s the controversial take: that dub is an absolute gem.